Metrics get more formalised and less discretionary as a company matures.
Rob Green, Founder of Darwin Total Rewards, has seen this shift play out repeatedly between private and listed companies: "In the private world there is more of a discretionary element. At a listed company the measurement becomes much more defined and focused – more KPI-driven, more tied to company-wide performance rather than individual judgement calls."
Common measures at more mature companies include revenue growth, EBITDA, operating margin, and earnings per share, increasingly alongside non-financial metrics like ESG.
As Rob puts it, "the metrics themselves become more complex but more generic" – more structured, and more tied to outcomes the whole company can see, rather than judgement calls made behind closed doors.
This formalisation also comes with governance attached.
Malus and clawback provisions – allowing a company to reduce or recover a bonus before or after payout, typically triggered by misconduct, regulatory enforcement, or a financial restatement – become standard practice once bonus structures reach this level of scrutiny, and should be built into design from the outset.